Unpious — an archiveVoices on the Hasidic Fringe · 2010–2014
search all archives
Home › 2010 › January

Great Expectations

By Pen Tivokeish · January 11, 2010

A mixture of apprehension and desperation radiated off young Srulik’s face. “Rebbe, the note, the note” he said in a voice that portrayed disappointment. He could finally rest a tired arm that had been raised with pride and promise, for the Rebbe had finally decided to heed his call.

“What note” said Rebbe Klar impatiently. “Why is it that I can’t proceed for five minutes without interruption. huh, why?” asked the Rebbe.

“Rebbe, I brought you a note this morning asking that I be excused at eleven. My father will be outside waiting.”

Rebbe Klar was always cross. Teaching a class of twelve year old boys was taxing. The pay was inadequate, the work load demanding, the material boring and the boys; well exhausting. There was a knock at the classroom door.  ”Come in” said Rebbe Klar in an elongated monotone, one that betrayed his premonition that this was a carrier pigeon, a pupil on errand for a colleague. Perhaps the teacher next door had run out of blackboard chalk or perhaps the courier held a note. It might perhaps read “are you going to that chuppah later or not, and can I have a lift”.

But it was none of these, it was Srulik’s father who tentatively pushed the door open and popped his head through the classroom doorway keeping his feet firmly outside. “I am Sorry for interrupting,” he said with a mustered smile, “but I sent a note with Srulik, he should have been outside school five minutes ago”.

“Ah, I am so sorry” said Rebbe Klar with an equally plastered smile, as he motioned to Srulik indicating that he was free to go.

Srulik’s father was cross. “Why couldn’t you be on time”? he asked. “The Rebbe wouldn’t let me go” said Srulik apologetically. The father had taken time off work, he was running late. The duo made their way together to the car and hardly a word was exchanged between them.

He was on his way to choose a hat, a coat, a few suits, bekishes, the complete Bar Mitzvah package at B&G . Pre-Bar Mitzvah Shopping Day was a day he had been looking forward to. A day his friends had spoken of so often. He would stand at the centre of the universe on that day, placed there by shop owners and by parents alike, they promised. Yet here he was with his father at the hat shop, despondent and glum.

The hat man, measured his head, tried a wider brim, a taller crown and a bigger size. “Stand straight,” he said, and Srulik did. His father decided on a hat of the right proportions and they progressed to the suit section. And so it was throughout the escapade, he was sized up and looked upon from side to side, but he didn’t choose much, save for two suit designs and between a few bekishe floral patterns. Srulik felt small as a storm brewed beneath his eyes.

He walked back to the car taking nothing home. The clothes needed alteration and the hat needed to be brushed and set. His father drove to work, and he returned to an empty class. His peers were out at play. Srulik sat down in his seat. He rested his tired head upon the desk as tears trickled down his cheeks. The floodgates that had held up thus far gave way.

But in preparation to Jewish adulthood he had learnt an important lesson that day: Haredi life is never about what you want as an individual. Rebbe Klar had not chosen his job, Srulik’s father had not chosen to have a child of thirteen at 32. The hat man made hats, but did not design them.

Srulik will not choose an academic study path nor will he choose his bride. He will not style his wedding, and he will not name his child. He will not choose the school that that child attends and upon death he will not choose his funeral casket.

Tags: family
Recovered from the Wayback Machine (copy of 2012-04-28). Original page in the Wayback Machine.

5 Responses

goylegamre · January 13, 2010 at 3:45 am

It kind of sets it into perpective as to how much b’chire there is the Haredi world. How do the Rabbunim incorporate the Judaic value of “free will” and living according to their rules with sever punitive actions for not obliging?

Amazing article as always, Pen!

Baal Habos · January 13, 2010 at 8:33 am

Pen, that was a very touching post with deep insight. I think it goes to the core of why I feel the way I do, and my world is nowhere near as stifling as the Chassidish world. Yet I think it’s catching up.

e · January 14, 2010 at 6:13 pm

וואָס בחירה?
ein l’cha ben chorin ela mi she’osek batorah!

Totally Content · January 15, 2010 at 12:53 am

Thanks for this highly entertaining piece. I know it wasn’t intended as comedy, but seriously! Was it supposed to make me all sad and heartbroken? Was I supposed to feel bad for the poor kid who wasn’t possibly having those thoughts? And if by the off chance that he was, if at the tender age of 12.5 this kid was already feeling caged – then you know quite well, that HE knew quite well, that he would indeed have a say in much of those choices. Except for those nonsensical choices that just don’t matter. Not on any remotely significant level.

Except for that casket. Now THAT decision is important. Maybe it just seems that way because I did have a say in my education. And in whom I married. And in my wedding design (of course my choson so desperately wanted to be fully involved, but damned rules kept him away. He cried and cried…) We did also have a say in the name of our kids. And in the schooling. But the lack of choice in casket design… heart wrenching. Weeks I tell, months even! we’ve stayed up at night agonizing over the right that was robbed from us. Behind closed doors we play with the mini models, because well, we know we can’t ever afford the full size version.

My personal dream? I would love to go with the elmwood in dark red mahogany finish, and the light champagne velvet interior. I’m still iffy on the exact model, but I’ve narrowed it down to either the Royale or the Capri. Or there’s always Remington. I mean, she’s classic.

And then I remember that it isn’t up to me. At all. *sniffle* The sacrifices we make to live this life…

Pen Tivokeish · January 15, 2010 at 3:44 am

Well, our boys all dress uniquely, don’t they?

You can pretend that boys love yeshiva all you want, but in reality, how can a one size fits all syllabus, work? Is there anything that even resembles academic choice within the yeshiva system?

If there is one thing that is most painful about our way of life, it is the obliteration of those prime years. Yeshiva is for boys, an excruciatingly boring experience. Our mashgiach used to say, that in a good yeshiva, a top bochur actually studies around 3 hours each day and wastes the rest, now I wonder why that would be eh? not bad and useless content?

Pray tell, what percentage of shidduchim collapse after the first or second “beshow”? Is it not somewhere between say 4% and 0.1%? Does that not tell you that most boy and girls do NOT choose their spouse but depend upon parental choice because they are to unworldly to assume that role and feel that way?

You grapple with this very issue on you own blog, although the matter is duly resolved by invoking YHWH, (slight correction there, it is 40 days prior to the child being formed in the womb not birth), but as a woman who chose not to be versed in the Talmudic texts that rule you, you don’t know that Rashi adds that “זיווג ראשון של האדם הוא לפי מזלו”, predetermined luck, exciting prospect! He does not say as you do, that ones spouse as hand-picked by the master will be perfect, no, it might be mismatch of the year, but tough luck literally!

I am sure your own wedding reflected your personality, or perhaps did it look exactly like all those other humongous, unaffordable and perfectly streamlined weddings in the shtetel, or wait sorry, but you got to choose the napkin colours didn’t you, right, sorry I forgot.

I suppose you do not have any deceased grandparents, and so you really do choose a name for your kids, but nah most of us do not choose names for our children. Of course for numbers 5 – 15 that is when you do get to choose. The Rebbe approves and your on to something.

If I remember correctly, most Belz born kids attend Belz affiliated schools.

You do keep an organ donor card don’t you? Is there anything remotely comedic about a community of people who world over, benefit from donated organs, but who do not contribute? Altruism not our strong point here, is it?

← BBC on Chasidim Who Leave  |  Welcome, Pen Tivokeish! →