Unpious — an archiveVoices on the Hasidic Fringe · 2010–2014
search all archives
Home › 2011 › March

“He Who Acquires Wisdom”

By Velvel Belkin · March 11, 2011 · Reflections

[Reflections]

It began to irk me as a young 14 year old, still still early on in “the system,” still idealistic and naive about yeshiva and Lubavitch.  I was the first of my classmates to get one, which made me feel weird, uncomfortable, and different. I never felt superior or special because of it, rather I always felt awkward.

As time went on, I became part of the majority who had it, as opposed to the minority. But that was only in the system; outside of the system it still made me feel strange. It labeled me as a religious man, a rabbi, a fanatic, things that I am not.

However much knowledge I acquired of sports, politics, and secular music, I still felt different. I could sit in a bar and have a discussion about the Mets and drink a beer, but as much as I aspired to fit in, there was always this that set me apart. When I went home in order to be liberated from the system for a little while, I would put on a t-shirt and a baseball cap to go to the mall, but even that would not shake the feeling that I was different because of it.

When I traveled to a Slifkin lecture titled “How to (Not) be a Heretic,” it caused me to be  labeled as a Chasid, a Charedi, a fanatic, when in reality some of my views about religion are heretical even by their standards .

Sitting in a Modern Orthodox shul in Teaneck with people who were similar to me haskafically, I  realized it was a barrier that hashkafa couldn’t break. Sitting in that shul I felt like an alien amongst men, a foreigner amongst citizens.

I remember a time when I would have prided myself on being the only one to have it, wore it as a badge of honor, but now it is just a relic of my past, chains that bind me to a world that I don’t relate to anymore and feel much anger towards.

Many women, when writing about ridding themselves of their sheitels, express a small twinge of pain about losing a “part of themselves.” I cannot imagine feeling that way about losing it , but I guess they couldn’t imagine feeling that way either beforehand.

The only trace of having it that I can imagine is, sometimes stroking it absent mindedly while deep in thought.

Tags: beards, Chabad, conforming
Recovered from the Wayback Machine (copy of 2013-08-03). Original page in the Wayback Machine.

3 Responses

quasi-intellectual quasi-chussid · March 12, 2011 at 7:05 pm

Thanks for a cute, sweet and witty essay; but, I’d say, rather short and sparse for such a long and thick subject!
Also it’s a bit unclear, perhaps intentionally so, if you still grow it, or you let it go; I’m curious to know.
Toward the end of this essay you tossed in a real loaded topic, kind of as an aside and slight of hand. Comparing/contrasting the two sides of the mechitzeh and their respective experiences of “Unpiousing”, is a topic that, I feel, has yet to be even surface-scratched.

AM Yehuda · March 13, 2011 at 9:26 am

Nice piece! I like your creative exploration of this subject.

Velvel Belkin · March 18, 2011 at 12:15 am

Both your compliments are appreciated ,and encouraging. I am especially happy that AM Yehudah complimentred me , because he is truly a great writer whos pieces I always enjoy reading immensely. Yes quasi-intellectual quasi-chussid If I make an active decision about “it” then I will write about it here.

← I Hate It Because I Love It  |  Blank, Blank, Blank: An Autobiography →